As a fellow North Carolinian and conservative republican i was a witness to the NC Republican GOP actions to supvert the election process and nulify North Carolinian right to a free and fair election. Whatley as chairman of the NC Republican GOP did the very minal to ensure North Carolinians votes were counted fairly in the 2020, 2021 and 2022 elections. The first hand account of what took place at the NC Republican GOP 2023 Convention was edviance of his lack of interity in the ensuring creditablity in elections even with in his own party.